Monday, September 22, 2008

Why I Hate Affirmative Action

There are few things in the world that make me feel like another “goddamn chink” but one of these things is affirmative action. The official definition of affirmative action quickly taken off of Wikipedia is:
Affirmative action in the United States is intended to promote access to education, employment, or housing among certain designated groups (typically, minorities and women). The stated motivation for affirmative action policies is to redress the effects of past discrimination and to encourage public institutions such as universities, hospitals and police forces to be more representative of the population. It is commonly achieved through targeted recruitment programs, by preferential treatment given to applicants from designated groups, and in some cases through the use of quotas.
The real definition of affirmative action is this: If you’re middle-class white or Chinese-Asian, forget about going to the college of your dreams or getting need-based financial aid. But wait, you say. You’re Asian. Doesn’t that make you a minority? Not quite. You see, affirmative action is tricky. It only helps the minorities in college. And since Asian-Americans are actually a majority in some colleges now (at Stanford, last I checked, 60% of the undergraduate students were of Asian descent), that means for college admissions we might as well be white.
Affirmative action punishes those who have difficult backgrounds but have worked hard to succeed and become the middle-class. It is exactly this success that keeps them now from being able to receive any financial help. Affirmative action also punishes my parents and me for being a certain race. My parents are immigrants too, but successful, Chinese ones. Can it truly be their fault that my parents scrimped and saved their way through higher college education? We lived in apartments, wore second-hand and discount clothing, and even went without cable TV (Actually, we still don’t have cable). Our first TV lasted twenty years, and my parents couldn’t even afford to buy it – they picked it up off a curb before the garbage trucks got to it. But somehow this doesn’t even matter anymore, because now our family income is high enough to be high middle-class. Never mind that my dad still works two stressful jobs. Never mind that my mother works part-time at a library on top of raising three kids. We’re Chinese; we’re middle-class; there’s nothing else we need to make us happy besides extra math homework
Maybe it’s fear that keeps us down. China’s global power is rising, and the recent Beijing Olympics may be just the starting pistol shot in the worldwide race of global domination. Maybe it’s the fear that one day, everyone will have to speak Mandarin (never mind that the “power language” is English now, that’s fine). Or maybe it’s just the sight of us, our yellow skin and our slanty eyes, that makes their stomachs turn. For my part, I’m genetically blessed to look a bit more “Western” – larger eyes, high cheekbones, and “an oddly prominent ass,” as my friend likes to say. So maybe when they finally burn us as witches I’ll escape, but I won’t count on it. You see, I’ll be in the minority.

//written for my polemic assignment

2 comments:

JC said...

Hey! I said I am going to read your blog, but today is when I actually sat down and started reading them. I feel your pain with financial aid and being Asian, especially Chinese. My parents worked so hard so I can get a good education, but I still remember the days when we got mattresses that people threw away and we wore coats at home during winter in NY because heat was expensive. I feel that most Asian parents value education so much that they work extremely hard to let their children have a good education, especially saving for college-- that when time comes for college financial aid, fuck, you don't get any, even if you lived in the dumpster for 10 years of your life.

In programs for minority students, there's 5% Asians at most (and most likely not Chinese). In studies where they talked about minorities, Asians don't even show up half of the time. Sometimes I wonder if we are even an "minority" anymore...

Speaking of people fearing China, I think it is a combination of not knowing about the country + economic fear + still viewing China as a third-world enemy in a way. One thing I observed this past year made me really sad: when the tsunami hit a couple years ago, everyone was mobilized to donate and help out. It was constantly in the news for months. When China had the horrible earthquake, however, it was only on TV for about... 2 week? not even? And all the fundraisers we have seen are organized by Asian people and the attendees are 99% Asian people. No one else seemed to care. Perhaps they thought that China is rich enough to take care of itself. Or perhaps, they are just indifferent towards a country that may become a threat to them in the future.

AH i am just ranting at 1AM in the morning because I can't sleep. If I am completely off topic, sorry!

Miss you a lot!

--JC

PS: got your postcard! yay!
PPS: we have ants in the apt, so hopefully it's still all intact when you come back! =P

tiajones said...

Hi Elaine,

My name is Tia and I'm an editor at OpposingViews.com, the debate website. Since we both cover race issues, I thought I'd drop you a note. I would've e-mailed you but I couldn't find an address.
See, we're currently having a discussion about whether or not we still need affirmative action. You can see it here:
http://www.opposingviews.com/questions/do-we-still-need-affirmative-action
Although vetted experts are the ones doing the debating, anyone can contribute by choosing a side and posting comments about the experts' arguments.
Check it out and, if you have the time, let me know what you think at tia@opposingviews.com
Thanks!